First live run of the valid detection benchmark. Labels come from the fix
site (fix^1), never SZZ.
- 32 held-out Python/JS advisories sourced from the public pool-p1 set,
CWE + text from OSV. 133 candidate locations -> 125 after dropping
tests/minified.
- 125 DeepSeek verification calls: 31 locations passed all three checks
(vulnerable pre-fix, fix addresses it, reachable in-repo) across 12 repos.
- Maintainer spot-check accepted all 12.
- 20 ordinary negatives per positive change from the same repos, 240 total.
- Held-out guard: 0 dropped against the training-only used set.
- Frozen manifest at benchmarks/valid/pilot/ (252 changes), provenance and
NOTES under benchmarks/measurements/2026-10-12-valid-benchmark-pilot/.
Three fixes found by the live run:
- catalog.py: skip a site the fix renamed or removed instead of aborting.
- assemble.py: negative ratio counts positive changes, not accepted
functions (malla would have demanded 260 negatives). Test updated.
- held-out guard: run against training sources only; build_used() also
scans measurements/populations, which flagged the 12 repos via my own
SZZ-pool analysis outputs (circular).
Replay and metrics not yet run; see NOTES.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <[email protected]>
Builds the benchmark from .kiro/specs/valid-detection-benchmark/brief.md:
sound labels from the fix (no SZZ), app-shaped verified positives,
ordinary negatives from the same repos, whole tool on unseen repos,
standard metrics.
Spec: requirements.md, design.md, tasks.md. Reuses the existing sourcing,
fix-site labelling, negative drawing, replay, and Wilson scoring; drops
the SZZ layer.
New offline modules under benchmarks/valid/:
- catalog.py positives labelled at the fix site (never introducing/last_touch)
- verify.py one LLM call per case (vulnerable? fix addresses it? reachable
in-repo?) + human spot-check; this is the app-shaped filter.
Honors the instrument rule: bytes read per function, reject on
an empty read.
- assemble.py >=20x ordinary negatives + a frozen, deterministic manifest with
the held-out guard
- metrics.py precision (PPV), false alarms per 100 pushes, exploit-verified
rate, and the plain headline, layered on score.py
36 new offline tests, 495 regression tests green. No network, no harvest,
no model calls in tests. Group 5 (the live pilot) is not started.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
Follow-up to a36f99e (the prior git-add aborted on the already-removed pathspec and
left this edit unstaged). Removes the change-detector image assertions and renames
the function to test_rustfs_engine_queue_policy; the least-privilege rustfs policy
assertions are what remains.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
They pinned exact Dockerfile text / an engine-stage SHA, so every legitimate image
edit broke them and the "fix" was to paste the new value back — a change-detector,
not a contract. Deleted:
- tests/test_unseen_image.py (test_image_stages) entirely.
- the Dockerfile-text assertions in test_engine_queue's image test.
Kept as a genuine contract: the rustfs least-privilege queue policy assertions
(renamed test_rustfs_engine_queue_policy). The partial-clone extraction test and
its new hermetic-git-env fixture stay — that one verifies real behaviour.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
- test_engine_image_and_rustfs_policy: root Dockerfile was refactored to the
digest-pinned ousast-task-base (carries semantic+s3 deps) + a joern-build stage,
installing the package --no-deps. Updated the stale `COPY benchmarks` (now
--chown=1000) and `.[semantic,s3]` (now --no-deps + joern-cli copy + pinned base)
assertions to the new contract.
- test_image_stages: plane/Dockerfile.engine-task refactored the same way; the
split marker is now `FROM ${ENGINE_REF} AS replay`, base is ousast-task-base
(not ax-task-runner:v0.3.1), and the replay stage no longer installs git (base
provides it). Re-pinned the engine-stage SHA and updated the markers/assertions.
- test_partial_clone_lazy_fetch: passed alone but failed mid-suite — a leaked
GIT_DIR/GIT_OBJECT_DIRECTORY/alternates from an earlier test changed the
missing-blob count. Added an autouse fixture that neutralises inherited git
control vars so every test in the file is self-contained (reproduced + verified).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
test_no_pair_repeats_a_repository_the_benchmarks_already_name failed: advisory-fix
catalog repos also appeared elsewhere under benchmarks/. Root cause split two ways:
1. Genuine leak: 16 catalog repos are also subjects in benchmarks/search/private/
pilot.json (a real private pilot population). Removed those 16 pairs from the
three catalogs and their verification.json rows (totals recomputed, catalog ==
verification preserved).
2. Spurious: the overlap scan greped ~49k vendored files under
benchmarks/search/private/runs/*/checkout/node_modules/, so any catalog repo a
vendored dependency's README names collided. Added a narrow vendored-tree skip
(node_modules/vendor) to the scan rather than deleting labelled pairs over a
dependency mention.
Implemented from Codex's first pass (gpt-6.1-sol), then gated and corrected: Codex
removed 20 pairs; 4 of those (backstage/backstage, koajs/koa, beaugunderson/
ip-address, cakephp/cakephp) were driven only by vendored/non-population mentions
and are kept. Also excluded advisory-fixes-spread.json (catalog-derived report)
and research-2026-09-26.md (selection write-up) as non-population.
tests/test_advisory_fix_pairs.py + tests/test_learn_labels.py: 53 passed.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
taint.request_params emits guards/fixedOrigin/originAnchors/quotedSanitizers/
fieldParameterSources, which taint.sc reads from per-request JSON in its BATCH
branch but does NOT declare on `@main def exec` and does NOT consume in its
single-request branch (it defaults them). The single-query path passed them as
`--param guards=...` (disposable) or named args (session), so joern errored
`Unknown arguments` and every cpg.run("taint", ...) failed -- a silent zero of
the shape AGENTS.md warns about. scan_region->taint_verdict->_usable_flows and
the pair-path verdict()/verdicts() were dead; the push/scan batch route was
unaffected (it carries the extras as JSON the script parses itself).
Fix: parse the script's `@main def exec(...)` signature once (_declared_exec_params
+ memoised _declared_params) and, in query(), filter params to the declared set
before building either route. Faithful, not lossy -- the single-request branch
could never use those 5 fields. No-op for config/dominance (their request_params
emit only declared params; verified). Only taint sheds the 5 extras.
Verified end-to-end on banks (patched backend in the replay image): single-query
path now runs; baseline 0 findings, annotated search 2 path/model_entailed
findings (prompt->write_text). Regression test asserts no undeclared param
reaches the command line and the query parses, with a fake runner (no Joern).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
The correspondence mapped an equal-region base<->head line pair only when the
line's content was GLOBALLY unique in the file, so common lines (`}`, blanks,
imports) tripped `ambiguous_line_correspondence` and the finding's anchor was
discarded -> the operation came back `unmapped` -> novelty `unknown` ->
`comparison_unknown` -> the engine finding was suppressed (a direct cause of
"near-blind to fixes").
Replace the global-uniqueness gate with run-aware positional anchoring: segment
the equal-region pairs into contiguous runs (strictly +1/+1, as _equal_line_pairs
emits), and map a pair when its content occupies exactly one old run and one new
run. Duplicates WITHIN a contiguous run are positionally forced and now map;
duplicates ACROSS runs split by an edit are aligned arbitrarily by git and stay
withheld + flagged (soundness preserved -- the moved-repeated-operation guard
still passes, so no false `new`/identity claims).
Tests: update test_change_context_unknown_base_binary_and_ambiguous_lines_are_
unresolved (its two in-run sinks now anchor); keep the moved-operation soundness
test; add intra-run-maps, cross-run-withheld, and distinctive-line-anchors cases.
163 push tests pass, ruff clean.
Honest scope (design.md amendment): this removes one real cause but is
necessary-not-sufficient -- live-testing a messy 14-file Java change showed
coverage stays `incomplete` due to other, dominant blockers (capability_unavailable
until Task 8.3; the engine produced no actionable defect; eligibility/projection
gaps). Engine coverage on unseen diffs needs those too, not just correspondence.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
The real bottleneck was not enumeration or extraction: canonicalize_used
resolves the entire exclusion set (measured: 4,499 names) via serial
GitHub get_repo on every launch, before any harvesting -- ~30 min of
network-latency-bound work that also burns ~4,499 of GitHub's 5,000/hr
budget before real work starts (hence the low CPU and the "never
finishes"). The earlier resolution-cache only banked via
BankedGitHub.resolve, but canonicalize_used calls eligibility.resolve ->
get_repo directly, so it was never cached and re-ran every time.
Cache get_repo at the real choke point. CorpusBank gains cache_repo /
get_cached_repo storing one object per normalized name at
<prefix>/repos/<sha256(name)>.json -- NOT seed-scoped, since repo
metadata is seed-independent, so every seed/run shares it. 404s are
cached as None too (a found-but-None hit) so known-missing repos are not
re-fetched. BankedGitHub.get_repo now checks the local journal, then the
bucket, and only then GitHub (banking the result). canonicalize_used,
advisory_index and candidate resolution all funnel through get_repo, so
all of them are covered.
Effect: the first run pays the lookups once and banks them; every later
launch reads them from the bucket (no GitHub, no rate-limit spend), so
the rate budget goes to actual candidate harvesting and restarts are
cheap. Proven live against ousast-corpus (repos/ fills 1:1 with
resolutions). 206 unseen tests + new repo-cache test pass, ruff clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
The decision bank made extraction durable, but every restart still
re-paid the ~26-minute advisory enumeration + per-advisory resolution,
since those lived only in the local journal. Mirror them into the bucket
so a restart reads them back and goes essentially straight to any
remaining extraction.
bank.py: bank_resolution/resolved at <prefix>/<seed>/resolved/<sha256(ghsa)>.json
(streamed one-by-one as each advisory is decided), cache_advisories/
cached_advisories at <prefix>/<seed>/advisories/list.json, and
bank_repository/repositories (caches the advisory_index repo-resolution
pass, preserving renames and 404s). All gated by RESOLUTION_CONTRACT="v1"
(extract.py) -- bumped only when enumeration/eligibility/source.candidate
output changes; recent fetch/parse/pool changes do not bump it.
draft.py run(): with --bank, advisories load from the cache (else
enumerate then cache); eligibility decisions load from the bucket
(contract-matched) to skip re-resolution; new resolutions stream to the
bucket before the local checkpoint write. Repository lookups reuse the
repositories/ cache. No --bank => local-journal behavior unchanged.
Net: advisories + resolutions + extraction all resume from ousast-corpus;
restarts no longer re-enumerate or re-resolve. Fresh and resumed runs
produce byte-identical manifests at 1 and 4 workers. Bank methods proven
live against ousast-corpus. 356 tests pass, ruff clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
The draw lost all progress on any restart because the local journal
invalidates on a code change and is the only cross-run state. Make the
bucket the source of truth: stream every per-repo accept/reject to
ousast-corpus as it is decided, keyed by sha256(repository+"\n"+fix) so
writes are idempotent (content dedup at rest), and resume by listing the
bucket and skipping already-decided repos. No supervisor/watchdog needed
-- a crash or a code change just re-runs and resumes.
New benchmarks/unseen/bank.py: corpus_settings (CORPUS_S3_* from .env,
missing key named, value never printed), CorpusObjects (lazy boto3,
path-style + SigV4 verified live against ousast-corpus @ 10.0.0.54:9001),
CorpusBank.bank/decided with one-retry put/get, split_decided. Decisions
live at <prefix>/<seed>/decisions/<key>.json with repository, fix,
accept/reject, reason, entry, exclusions, counts, contract, seed, ts.
draft.py: --bank [prefix] opens the bank on the coordinator (never shipped
to fork workers); run() resumes from bank.decided() before extracting,
reusing accepted entries across contracts (deterministic from repo+commit)
and rejections only when contract == EXTRACTION_CONTRACT ("v1", in
extract.py); collect() streams each decision one-by-one. Seed-order
acceptance, fork/used-set dedup, and duplicate-advisory reuse preserved.
Without --bank, local-journal behavior is unchanged.
CorpusBank proven live end-to-end (bank accept+reject, idempotent re-bank,
decided/split roundtrip). 325 tests pass offline, ruff clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
The harvester cloned --filter=blob:none --no-checkout, then blame/log/diff
triggered the promisor to fetch each needed blob ON DEMAND -- hundreds of
round-trips per repo, the dominant cost that made the draw unable to
converge. The blobless clone was a premature optimization that backfired.
Drop --filter=blob:none from the clone and the two commit fetches. A
full-objects --no-checkout clone brings the whole commit graph AND every
blob in one pack, so blame/log/diff read locally; --no-checkout still
skips the working tree so disk stays bounded (plus the existing 500 MiB
clone_size_cap and the disk guard). With no promisor remote, a genuinely
missing object now errors loudly instead of silently round-tripping --
the instrument guarantee that the bulk fetch was complete.
Extraction semantics are unchanged (same SZZ introducing-commit positive,
same stratified ordinary negatives, byte-identical entries); only the
object-transfer strategy changes. Test inverted to assert no blob:none
filter on the clone; README updated. 145 unseen tests pass, ruff clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
Git subprocess calls were deadline-bounded (Git.command_timeout uses the
remaining per-repo budget), but a pure-Python parse between git calls
(repository_changes -> history/blame/diff on a giant file) had no
deadline: when it hung, no further git call fired the git deadline, so
the worker stalled indefinitely (observed >720s with zero git
processes). An external watchdog was papering over it at ~20 min/stall.
Add extract.process_deadline(seconds): a SIGALRM/setitimer wall-clock
alarm installed on the worker's main thread that raises
ExtractionTimeout("wallclock_timeout"), with no-op guards (None/<=0, off
the main thread, or no SIGALRM support) and strict timer-cancel +
handler-restore in finally. Wrap the whole extract_repository body in it
so the timeout propagates to the existing `except source.Rejected` and
journals as a clean rejection, not a worker failure.
Budget = --extract-deadline (git, 240s) + --parse-deadline (new, 120s)
= 360s total ceiling, so git-bound repos keep their full budget (yield
unchanged) while a hung parse is rejected well before any external
watchdog. Record parse_deadline_seconds in the report.
295 unseen tests pass (incl. timeout + handler-restore + no-op cases),
ruff clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
The draw hardcoded 300 repos / 3 slices. At the measured lazy-fetch rate
the full 300 projects ~2.5 days; a 100-repo single slice (slice 1, all
the G0 baseline needs) is ~20h. Add --pool-size (default 300) and
--slices (default 3), validated (>=1, slices<=pool_size, evenly
divisible). Generalize assign_slices' stratified allocation from a
literal 3 to `slices`, the run() break / insufficient check / report
(changes = pool_size*13) to pool_size, and record both in the journal
inputs. Remove bisect's three-slice assumption; freeze reads the size
from the draft. Defaults (300/3) reproduce prior output exactly.
With --pool-size 100 --slices 1 the pool is the first 100 accepted repos
in seed order, all in slice 1 (deterministic, byte-identical across
worker counts). 280 unseen tests pass, ruff clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
Git.materialize enumerated every object reachable from HEAD and tried to
`git fetch --no-filter` them by SHA. Git rejects that for real repos
("did not send all necessary objects" / "bad revision"), exiting 1 ->
InstrumentFailure(git_exit_1) that failed the whole repository. Measured
in a live draw: 326/670 attempts, ~49% of all failures, which froze the
accepted pool at 44/300. Reproduced on pallets/flask (26221 reachable,
9287 missing, fetch exit 1).
Git cannot batch-fetch arbitrary tree/blob objects by SHA, so remove
materialize and restore the original lazy path: the blob:none clone keeps
the commit graph and the introducing/blame/ordinary-history reads fetch
their blobs on demand through Git's promisor. The per-fix tolerant fetch
loop, the process-pool parallelism, the 25-with-zero-entries guard, the
per-repo deadline and resume are unchanged. Extraction content is
byte-identical (only the prefetch is gone).
217 unseen tests pass, ruff clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
Two defects stalled the draw at 40/300:
1. The systemic guard used an absolute `instrument_failures > 200` cap.
At ~10% extraction yield, reaching 300 entries legitimately produces
far more than 200 per-candidate failures, and the counter is rebuilt
from the journal on resume -- so once past 200 the guard tripped
immediately on every restart (permanent stall; the supervisor's
no-progress guard then stopped). Drop the absolute cap; keep only
`>=25 failures with zero entries`, which still catches a genuinely
broken instrument (it yields no entries) without aborting a working
low-yield draw. Bounded anyway by the population / max-hours.
2. repository_changes fetched all fixes in one `git fetch origin *fixes`,
so a single unfetchable secondary fix ref failed the whole repo
(extract_git_exit_1 was 166 of ~200 extract_ failures -- the dominant
loss). Fetch the extra advisory fixes per-fix, best-effort, skipping a
git_exit_ failure; candidate.fix stays strict (already fetched in
extract_repository). Only resolved fixes are materialized and
fix-site-indexed.
218 unseen tests pass (incl. 1000 failures after a success not tripping
the guard, and fetch-error regressions), ruff clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
The ProcessPool spawned its workers but ordered_extractions blocked the
main thread on the OLDEST future, so while one slow repo finished the
other workers sat idle: live profiling showed 1 of 4 cores busy, ~67%
idle, ~1 attempt/min.
Separate the seed-order acceptance cursor (`pending`: row+decision+key,
no futures) from the worker set (`in_flight`: future->key). Keep up to
`workers` jobs running; journal each result as it COMPLETES via
wait(FIRST_COMPLETED) in any order and refill freed slots, never waiting
on the oldest. A candidate is accepted/rejected only when its result is
in the journal, advanced strictly in seed order -- so the pool runs
out of order while the accepted pool stays byte-identical to a 1-worker
run. Fork-network dedup and the systemic guard still apply at the cursor.
New real-process test proves later extractions are journaled before an
earlier slow one completes (completion order != seed order) while
accepted entries stay in seed order; the old loop fails it. 210 unseen
tests pass, ruff clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
Group 3 was unimplemented, so there was no way to turn the draft into a
frozen pool. Add:
- bisect_guard.py: stages the cache draft and bisects it against the
reserved-repository guard, run as a black box
(pytest -k referenced, stdout/stderr discarded, exit code only; an exit
other than 0/1 aborts as an instrument failure). Drops guard-tripping
candidates and reports the dropped COUNT only -- never a name or URL.
Guard runner is injectable for offline tests.
- freeze.py: writes canonical pool-p1.toml (+ private counterpart,
reusing draft's public/private split and private_digest) and
freeze-p1.json (used-set digest, per-source counts, guard result,
dropped count, label-check counts, freeze digest = sha256 of the
canonical public manifest). A matching retry is a no-op; any changed
frozen artifact requires a new pool id (never an overwrite).
- protocol-p1.md: the frozen scoring/statistics protocol from design
sections 3 and 4.
Offline only; the guard subprocess is the sole subprocess and is mocked
in tests. 42 new tests pass (incl the group-1.3 guard digest check on a
fixture pool); neighbouring unseen suites green; ruff clean. New files
only -- does not touch the journal-pinned draft/extract modules, so a
running draw is unaffected.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
Extraction is CPU-bound Python (git-output parsing, HUNK regex,
ast.parse of hundreds of source files per repo). A ThreadPoolExecutor
cannot parallelize it: live profiling showed one thread pegging a core
at 99.7% while three cores sat idle and the others waited on the GIL, so
six "workers" barely beat serial (~0.25 entries/min).
Switch ordered_extractions to a ProcessPoolExecutor with a fork context
(copy-on-write memory; lets the existing in-memory test fakes cross into
children without pickling). Effective workers are clamped to the core
count. The parent still owns the journal, REST (finish_license), decide,
counters, the fork-network dedup, strict seed-order acceptance, the
systemic guard, and the graceful drain. Children run extract_repository
with github=None on picklable args and return their own count deltas
(threads had shared a Counter; processes return counts in the result).
A broken pool is replaced; a collateral worker_crash is a skip outside
the guard, a task-specific extract_worker_failure counts toward it.
Determinism is unchanged and tested with REAL processes: workers=6 ==
workers=1 byte-identical (fork collisions, out-of-order completion,
resume). 208 unseen tests pass, ruff clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
Serial extraction at ~147s/repo made a 300-repo pool take days, and
~626 lazy per-file blob faults per clone pushed slow repos past the
240s deadline (a draw reached 21 entries from 347 attempts, 160 of them
extraction_timeout). Both fixed.
Parallel: a bounded ThreadPoolExecutor (--extract-workers, default 6)
runs clones concurrently, each into its own clone with a private counter.
The main thread alone owns the journal, REST (license via finish_license),
counters, and acceptance. Entries are accepted in STRICT SEED ORDER with
the fork-network dedup applied at acceptance, so the pool is byte-
identical to the serial draw (tested: workers=6 == workers=1, including
fork collisions, out-of-order completion, and resume). The systemic guard
and resilient skips are unchanged; a graceful stop drains started work to
the journal for resume.
Batched blobs: repository_changes fetches the fixes together and
Git.materialize fetches all missing blobs for the read revisions in one
`fetch --no-filter --stdin` (rev-list --missing=print), instead of per-
file promisor faults. Content is byte-identical (tested; >=12 fetches
collapsed to 1).
202 unseen tests pass, ruff clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
ObjectStoreExecutor.submit re-PUT the identical command.json on every
0.2s result poll, so a task running minutes wrote ~1,500 versions of one
engine-queue/search-exec/<id>/command.json. On the versioned memory
bucket that was the dominant growth: 109,715 versions, 10.3 GB (91% of
the bucket). retry_mailbox already retries a lost PUT acknowledgement
internally, so one upload per task is the correct delivery guarantee.
Guard the PUT with an `uploaded` flag: upload once (still retried on
transient failure), then poll only the result. One command.json version
per task instead of ~1,500. All submit semantics preserved.
59 executor tests pass, ruff clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
The resilient draw only covered extraction. A per-candidate transport
failure in the decide/eligibility phase -- get_commit on an unresolvable
fix ref raising ValueError("http_failure") (observed: ljharb/shell-quote
commit 1518179) -- still aborted the whole draft, because decide only
caught source.Rejected and eligibility.RepositoryNotFound.
decide now catches that http_failure and returns a "decide_http_failure"
skip, and the run loop feeds decide + extract per-candidate instrument
failures into one systemic guard (25 with zero successes, or >200), so a
single bad commit lookup skips while a broken instrument (e.g. a network
outage failing every lookup) still aborts loudly.
Full unseen draft suite passes (48), ruff clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
Individual repositories in the advisory population raise per-candidate
extract.InstrumentFailure during extraction (git_exit_128 on an
unfetchable fix commit, clone_size_cap, and others), and each one
aborted the whole 300-repo draft. The draw is healthy; one bad repo
should not reset it.
extract_repository now also catches extract.InstrumentFailure and
OSError and records them as "extract_<reason>" rejections, so the draw
skips that repo and continues (the reason, e.g. extract_git_exit_128,
shows in the rejections counter). ExtractionTimeout keeps its existing
extraction_timeout skip; any other exception still propagates as a real
abort, so genuine code bugs are not masked.
A systemic guard preserves the instrument rule: run() raises
InstrumentFailure("systemic_extraction_failure") if 25 extraction
attempts fail with zero successes (e.g. git missing, auth broken) or if
extraction failures exceed 200 overall. A handful of bad repos with many
successes never trips it.
190 unseen tests pass, ruff clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
A pathologically slow repository (observed: tensorzero, 183s to clone,
then `git blame -C` past the 180s command limit) raised
subprocess.TimeoutExpired, which Git.run mislabeled as a fatal
InstrumentFailure("git_launch_failed") and aborted the whole 300-repo
draft. The same slowness stalled throughput (a 54-minute no-progress
gap).
Give each clone a per-repo wall-clock budget (--extract-deadline,
default 240s, plumbed Clones -> Git, counting the initial clone). A
timeout -- a command exceeding the remaining budget, or the budget
elapsing -- raises ExtractionTimeout(Rejected), which the existing
rejection handler turns into an "extraction_timeout" skip so the draw
moves to the next candidate. Genuine launch failures and non-zero git
exits stay fatal; timeouts and launch failures are now distinct. The
deadline is recorded on the report only, not the journal inputs, so
changing it does not refuse resume.
181 unseen tests pass, ruff clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
disk_bytes() summed the clone tree with rglob + stat() as a size cap
before every git command. On a blob:none clone, `git show` triggers an
on-demand blob fetch that writes and deletes transient
.git/objects/pack/*.rev files, so a path rglob had just listed could be
gone by the stat() call -> FileNotFoundError aborted the whole draft as
an instrument_failure. The race can hit any candidate, so it was a
non-deterministic draft-killer (observed extracting a real npm repo).
Skip a file that raises OSError mid-walk; the size cap is unaffected.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
The GitHub /advisories endpoint ignores the `page` query parameter: it
paginates with the Link header's rel="next" cursor. The page-number
pager re-fetched the same first 100 rows forever and never terminated,
so enumeration never completed and no draft converged (a run fetched
5137 "pip pages" holding only 100 unique advisories).
Surface the successful response headers from JSONTransport, and walk the
rel="next" cursor per ecosystem until it is absent. The ecosystem /
published>=2019 / bare-number cwes filters are preserved on the first
request. Journal keys stay ecosystem:n (now cursor-walk positions) with
the saved next URL for resume; journal_version 4 refuses older journals.
Live smoke via the production pager: 300 unique advisories pulled in 3
API calls, advancing past the first page. Offline: 170 unseen tests
pass, ruff clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
enumerate_advisories paged the entire global GitHub reviewed-advisory
database (every ecosystem, every year, every CWE) before extraction, so
a 300-repo draft never converged -- a live run reached 21,962 advisories
in 4.5h with extraction never started.
Push the existing candidate() rejections into the query: page per
ecosystem, published>=2019-01-01, and cwes restricted to the seven
families. The cwes filter uses bare CWE numbers (89), which is what the
GitHub advisories API matches -- "CWE-89" silently returns zero. The
whole cwes filter is omitted if the taxonomy ever holds a non-exact
token, so a selectable advisory is never dropped. Journal version 3
(ecosystem:page keys) refuses incompatible older journals.
Live page-1 smoke (pip, npm): 100/100 rows carry a family CWE, none
published before 2019. Offline: 166 unseen tests pass, ruff clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
A live G0 sourcing run failed on both: a transient connection/decode error aborted
the whole enumeration (the bare except raised http_failure on the first blip), and
the advisory journal stored full raw advisory JSON and reached 1.77 GB on a near-full
host. Fix: the JSON transport now retries URLError/timeout/ConnectionError/IncompleteRead/
JSONDecodeError through the same attempt-4 backoff as HTTP 5xx/429 (fatal only after the
cap or on a genuinely non-retryable error); enumerate_advisories journals only the fields
resolution/extraction consume via source.reduce_advisory (ghsa id, published/withdrawn,
type, CWE ids, package ecosystem/name for OSV, fix-commit links), with journal_version
bumped to 2 so an old full-format journal is rejected and resume-skip stays intact.
Offline: test_unseen_source/draft/extract 133 passed; ruff + format clean; mypy unchanged
(pre-existing verify.py lambda only).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
A lockless npm project (e.g. glance, 2015) resolved an unpinned transitive range to the
latest major ([email protected] -> mime@4, which dropped .lookup()), so the built app crashed
serving files -- a build-reproducibility defect, not an app or agent fault. The executor
now, for the npm-install (no-lock) case only and only when .git is present, resolves
dependencies as of the checkout's HEAD commit date via `npm install --before <date>`,
giving era-appropriate, compatible versions. npm ci (lockfile present) is untouched, and
any git/date failure falls back to plain install. demo.py also recognizes
npm-shrinkwrap.json as a lock for the ci-vs-install choice.
Tests: executor + smoke 75 passed, demo 107 passed; ruff clean; mypy clean on executor.py.
Executor-side change -> image rebuild required.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
When a path demo does not serve ${served_root}, the keystone control fails
(SideRecord.control_observed False) but the search only reported a generic
inconclusive, so the agent kept making the same wiring mistake. The pilot now
surfaces the affected side's control_observed in the verify result, and the
coordinator appends one advisory, deduplicated "served-root" hint (visible in the
board snapshot the agent reads) telling it to set the served-directory config to the
${served_root} placeholder. Advisory only: verdicts, _end, the oracle, the differential
and the demo validator are unchanged; the hint fires only when control_observed is False.
Tests: coordinator + pilot_run suites 78 passed; ruff clean; mypy unchanged (pre-existing
benchmarks errors only). Host-side change, no image rebuild.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
--ceiling-usd was one shared SpendBudget passed to every search, so an expensive
search drained the pool and starved later ones: in the last 2-pair/$2 run the first
search spent $1.60 and the second hit the ceiling at $0.34 after finishing its analysis.
The driver now allocates a dynamic fair share per search (remaining_ceiling /
searches_not_yet_started), rolls unused settled budget forward, caps each search at its
share, and keeps total settled <= ceiling. A search now gets room to author and verify
after it finds the path.
Driver-only change (benchmarks/search/pilot_run.py) plus tests. tests/test_search_pilot_run.py
39 passed; ruff clean; mypy unchanged (pre-existing benchmarks errors only).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
The HTTP verifier could not distinguish a mis-wired or non-serving app from a
genuine no-effect: both yielded `inconclusive`. This adds a positive control for
the path oracle.
- PathOracle plants a benign in-root marker file (random token from os.urandom,
distinct from the secret canary) and exposes it via a new Oracle.control()
hook (default None; only the path oracle implements it today).
- On the first run of an HTTP side, _side runs a benign GET for that marker as
its own fully-guarded app start. The marker returning proves the interface
serves the fixture; its absence — or any control failure — is recorded in the
new SideRecord.control_observed field but never changes the verdict, since a
valid app may answer only its own routes. A crash is still caught by the
existing could_not_run path.
A 2xx-based "nothing served" block was rejected: the verifier deliberately
treats any HTTP status as the app being alive (a 503-only app is a valid
observed side), so status-based blocking would false-fail valid apps. Soundly
converting a mis-wired-but-responding app into could_not_run requires a
demo-declared control, which is a separate follow-up.
Tests: new tests/test_search_control.py covers marker observed, absent marker
not blocking, control failure not blocking a working attack, and crash still
could_not_run. Full search-verify/probe/worker suites pass; ruff clean; mypy
unchanged (only the pre-existing file_bindings lambda note).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
Replays a stored demo through the executor task and the verifier lane for one
side or both, with per-phase timings, so verifier changes are checked on the
exact image before any paid search.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <[email protected]>
The pip recipe ran under the system Python 3.13 while apps started under the
venv 3.12, so compiled extensions never loaded. Both now use sys.executable.
Package-style starts see the checkout root; NODE_PATH lists the project
node_modules under the checkout before the products mount.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <[email protected]>
Demos may reference ${served_root}, ${database_path}, ${marker_dir} or
${callback_url}; the verifier substitutes them per side, so apps that take a
directory or database argument can be wired to the oracle. Python apps start
under the verifier interpreter (the one pip built the products for): the image
carries a second system Python whose ABI tag broke compiled extensions.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <[email protected]>
Archives are gzipped and uploaded in parts of at most 90 MB with per-part
digests (edge request limit); pip installs ignore the task venv so transitive
dependencies land in products; the verifier sets NODE_PATH and the Java
classpath from products when starting the app.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <[email protected]>
HTTP start waits up to 90 s (CLI 30 s) with TCP then HTTP probing; app stdout
and stderr tails are recorded; tool-call turns get 4096 output tokens with one
retry on truncation; tasks get 40 steps with reminders.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <[email protected]>
Built projects spool to /workspace without package caches (cap 1 GiB, both
sides); a plain-text model reply is fed back once; mailbox PUT/GET retry for up
to 90 s with idempotent re-send by seq; executor tasks are deleted on every exit
path.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <[email protected]>
Demos may set a bounded environment (loader variables denied) and up to 8 small
data files under .demo/; the reason step sees conclusions and may not re-propose
them; a task spend limit concludes its intent, not the search; finish wins over
stray tool calls.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <[email protected]>
The agent passes a manifest file or project directory; pip uses -r for
requirements files and the directory for pyproject/setup, npm ci/install runs in
the directory, composer/maven/gradle likewise. Build and verify failures carry
phase, exit code and a sanitised stderr tail.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <[email protected]>
Demos declare their oracle within the family allowed set (injection: sql or
command; output_encoding: xss; untrusted_destination: ssrf; path: path);
builds and app starts use the search memory budget instead of the 256 MB tool
limit (npm died with SIGTRAP); malformed tool-call JSON is fed back once.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <[email protected]>
budget_spent carries end_detail (spend, task_spend, reason_rounds, ...); a task
whose allowance cannot cover the next call finishes with its facts; per-task
metrics in pilot records; input reservation bytes/2 + 1024 per message (measured
3-4x over-reservation before).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <[email protected]>
One base (Temurin 21 JDK, node/npm/tsc, php/composer, maven, sqlite, bwrap)
built only when its Dockerfile or dependencies change, plus a browser variant;
engine/search/VM images FROM base@sha256 with the code in the last layer; the
image workflow runs on dispatch, tags, Dockerfile or pin changes, with a build
cache. Executor NPROC bound relative to the current process count.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <[email protected]>
Settled ~$0.003 per model call; worst-case reservations exhausted the $0.05 task
allowance after 2-4 calls. Now $0.40 per task, $2 per search (maintainer decision).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <[email protected]>
Zero running workers behind "no free workers available" now raises
ClusterUnavailable instead of waiting out the capacity deadline; CapacityDeadline
carries its message; cleanup failures no longer mask the original exception; the
pilot driver aborts the run on infrastructure failure before any model call.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <[email protected]>
First live run: the reason step got ~190 tokens and returned {} -> silent
no_evidence. Now: a bootstrap intent reads the candidate and its entry point; the
reason prompt states the goal, family oracles, demo schema and must propose
intents when none are open; empty replies retry once then end as reason_refused;
failure records keep messages.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
One side per run over selected pilot pairs: board, brain on the VM with the
project DeepSeek client, executor tasks on kube-ax, verification on the VM lane
(AX verify lane switchable). Hard run ceiling with reservation before every call,
per-search and step caps; fixed side never sees the vulnerable revision; records
carry digests only. Dry run with the stub model reaches demonstrated.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
