A4: roadmap-2026-09-04.md moves to .kiro/archive/steering/ so it no longer
loads as steering (roadmap.md and safety-net.md replaced it); roadmap.md's
pointer follows it. overview.md's spec table is recounted from tasks.md and
spec.json (adds ai-service-plane, harnessx-removal, learned-decision-engine,
pre-push-safety-net; drops the stale "active one"), and the module line now
cites the regenerated audit: 150 modules, 145 load-bearing, 5 standalone,
0 orphaned; 1,964 tests collected.
A5: a dated status note at the top of the requirements (or brief) of 16
specs: retired, superseded, dormant or complete, and for
model-grounded-detection the removal of judge/calibrate/execution (closing
the Req 10 execution-tier option). spec.json phase corrected to
implementation-complete where every task is checked (model-grounded-
detection, propose-adjudicate-prove, tree-sitter-overlay-extra,
corpus-seeded-mechanisms, pair-corpus-honesty); openrouter-sast-harness gets
a spec.json with status retired. Nothing deleted, no spec moved.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01EmM1j46qgKMh3zqD1QMwEo
11 requirements, 49 criteria. The outgrowth is addressed head-on and it leads,
because building on a superseded 99-module / 832-test surface is how this
session logged eighteen defects.
Req 1-3 are subtraction and come first:
1 remove the noise architecture by name -- rounds, acceptance, proposer,
journal, the K-run/floor/sign-test in scoring, the mechanism lever and
shape-search loop -- preserving the security *models* they carried. The
whole learning/ noise layer is absent from the gate path, so it deletes
without moving a gate.
2 reduce the 832 tests to what protects surviving behavior: a test that
pinned a deleted mechanism dies with it, every survivor maps to a
surviving requirement, and the "does nothing / greps --help / passes with
the capability absent" tests are removed outright.
3 audit all 99 modules -- load-bearing / standalone / orphaned -- and delete
the orphans, with fusion/mcp/skills/harness_ext/hunter_harness named for
an explicit keep-or-remove decision.
Req 4-8 adopt the CPG arbiter: Joern behind an optional extra (core stays
zero-dep, degrades to suspicion without it), the evidence ladder as the verdict
type, deterministic taint-reachability and guard-dominance verdicts, our
taxonomy and source/sink/sanitizer/guard models ported to CPG queries, and the
LLM reduced to a proposer whose claim the model checks -- no K-runs, no floor,
no acceptance rule, no evolve loop. Req 9 makes the corpus the model's
calibration set (a pair the model can't split is a named model gap). Req 10
keeps execution as a deferred, adopted-from-Clearwing tier for memory/C only.
Not approved.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <[email protected]>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01T7XD7x5KonMdmGRkp63EQG
