mirror of
https://github.com/norandom/OpenUltraSAST.git
synced 2026-10-16 03:49:26 +00:00
e0442d146cc91127eb3518d09b9089ee3063d1ee
8
Commits
| Author | SHA1 | Message | Date | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 Marius CiepluchandClaude Opus 5
|
e0442d146c |
fix(cpg): a graph the frontend emptied must not read as a clean repository
Scanning a two-file WordPress slice returned 64 regions examined, zero
findings and zero degradations. The graph it examined had no methods in it.
php2cpg 4.0.623 feeds several files to one `php-parse` process and reads its
stdout and stderr merged. php-parse writes a `====> File <next>:` banner to
stderr the moment it starts the next file, while the previous file's JSON --
megabytes of it -- is still draining from a block-buffered stdout. The banner
lands inside the JSON, ujson reports
expected json value or } got "=" at index 5011645
and the frontend drops that file. Reproducible on real plugin code, and the
size that matters is one file's AST dump, not the repository's:
class.memberorder.php alone (1834 lines) -> 142KB CPG, no failures
the same file + a two-line file -> 5.7KB CPG, BOTH dropped
One oversized file empties the whole graph. `joern-parse` then does not
propagate any of the frontend's warnings: 13 lines of output, exit status 0,
"Successfully wrote graph". This is what made a 637-file plugin unscannable
and reported it as clean -- it was never a scale limit.
Two fixes, because the failure arrives on two different paths:
* `_unparsed_files` reads the per-file warnings the frontend does emit, and
the scan reports them as `files_unparsed`. This covers the direct-frontend
path where the warnings are visible.
* The batched query now carries a `__census__` of the graph -- method and
file counts -- under a key no request id can collide with, and a scan over
a graph with no methods degrades as `cpg_empty`. This covers joern-parse,
which shows nothing. It rides the batch rather than costing its own
invocation, because avoiding a JVM start is the entire reason batching
exists.
Neither invents a verdict. There is no rung for "the graph was empty" because
the ladder labels verdicts and none was produced, which is exactly why it has
to be a degradation.
pmpro two-file slice before: 0 findings, degradations=[]
after: 0 findings, degradations=[cpg_empty]
Gates byte-identical; 840 tests pass.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <[email protected]>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01T7XD7x5KonMdmGRkp63EQG
|
||
|
Marius CiepluchandClaude Opus 5
|
21fdb554aa |
fix(cpg): a query that could not be asked is not an empty answer
contributor-scan 5.7, and it was the wrong question.
**The 117k-line pmpro CPG does not load.** Importing it throws in a
ForkJoinParallelCpgPassWithAccumulator during overlay application, so every
query against it returns nothing. It is not a call-graph question at all.
Isolated by running the ARBITER against two prebuilt CPGs rather than
writing a sixth ad-hoc Scala probe, four of which had already failed on my
own mistakes:
small wpdb CPG get_order_by_code -> 1 model_entailed
pmpro CPG getMemberOrderByCode -> 0
Both have their source and sink in ONE function, both were asked with
parameter sources and depth 3, same arbiter and same spec. The CPG is the
only difference.
That clears the facts, which is worth stating: `$wpdb` sinks work, the
parameter-source rule works, and a PHP parameter reaching `$wpdb->get_var`
through a concat is entailed. Whether php2cpg resolves `new X()` and
`$this->method()` is still unmeasured -- it cannot be measured on a CPG
that will not load -- and is recorded as 5.10 along with finding the size
boundary.
**And the defect underneath it, which is the fourth quiet failure found on
this one checkout.** `query_batch` returned `{}` for a failure and `{}` for
a genuine empty answer, so a caller could not tell "could not ask" from
"nothing found". Every query on this scan failed at load and it reported
500 regions examined, no findings, and no degradation: a vulnerable plugin,
clean.
A failed batch now returns None, unparseable output counts as a failure
rather than an empty answer, and the driver records a `query_failed`
degradation naming the kind and the request count.
This is the failure mode the rung ladder structurally cannot catch. Every
other honesty mechanism here labels a VERDICT -- suspicion,
regions_unjudged, regions_unasked, stated family limits -- and when no
verdict is produced there is nothing to label.
Gates byte-identical.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <[email protected]>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01T7XD7x5KonMdmGRkp63EQG
|
||
|
Marius CiepluchandClaude Opus 5
|
92677136d7 |
fix(cpg): a batch goes through a file, not the command line
Scanning a 637-file WordPress plugin reported 500 regions examined, zero
findings, and a taint query time of **0.05 seconds** -- less than a JVM
takes to start. Dominance ran for 29.56s and config for 22.44s in the same
scan, so only taint had failed.
Linux caps a SINGLE argument at MAX_ARG_STRLEN (128KB) whatever ARG_MAX
says. Measured on that plugin:
taint 2500 requests 1.49 MB <- over the cap
dominance 13 requests 0.04 MB
config 13 requests 0.00 MB
As `--param requests=<json>` execve returned E2BIG, `_run` caught the
OSError, `query_batch` returned {} -- and {} reads as "no rows found". Only
taint crossed the cap, which is exactly why the failure looked like a
result rather than an error.
This is the quiet failure the rung ladder cannot catch. Every other honesty
mechanism in this codebase labels a verdict; here no verdict was produced
to label, and a scan of a vulnerable plugin reported it clean.
The payload is now staged to a file beside the CPG and the path is passed
instead; all three queries read `requestsFile` when it is set and keep
`requests` for the single-request forms and the tests. A test asserts no
argument approaches the cap, since the failure mode is invisible at the
scale the unit tests run at -- batching worked on every small tree it was
ever tried on.
Verified on vampi first: 4 entailed, unchanged, all three known
vulnerabilities still found.
Gates byte-identical.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <[email protected]>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01T7XD7x5KonMdmGRkp63EQG
|
||
|
Marius CiepluchandClaude Opus 5
|
9c50e17c11 |
fix(cpg): retry a failed build through the language frontend
Scanning a 637-file WordPress plugin reported 1577 regions with 0 scanned and `cpg_build_failed`. The build was not slow or out of memory -- it failed in 42 seconds -- and `php2cpg` run directly on the same tree produced a 4.3MB CPG with no errors at all. The difference is that `joern-parse` detects the language and then shells out to the frontend in a separate process. On this tree it got as far as applying overlays and then threw, while still writing an unusable cpg.bin. Joern's own output recommends the direct route for a large codebase: "Invoking CPG generator in a separate process... If you are importing a large codebase (and/or running into memory issues), please try: invoke the frontend: php2cpg -J-Xmx3072m /tmp/src -o cpg.bin" So a failed `joern-parse` now retries through `<language>2cpg`, with the driver passing the dominant region language. A language with no mapping fails closed exactly as before -- no guessing at a frontend name. This is the documented fallback rather than a workaround, and it was diagnosed rather than assumed: the standalone build was run first, and only after it succeeded on the identical tree was the retry added. Gates byte-identical. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <[email protected]> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01T7XD7x5KonMdmGRkp63EQG |
||
|
Marius CiepluchandClaude Opus 5
|
177c7f3719 |
feat(model): first repository measurement, and the four things it found
contributor-scan 2.2. VAmPI at a pinned commit, scanned whole rather than as excerpts, with benchmarks/repos/measure.py recording build time, query time, arbitration time, peak memory, cost, unjudged regions, and whether each known vulnerability was found and at which rung. The corpus could not have found any of this. Every defect below needs a repository to become visible, and three of them were invisible behind a passing test suite. **The batch path was unreachable.** query_batch was implemented, tested and committed while CpgResult exposed only `run`, so the driver's capability check found nothing and fell back to one JVM per region-family: the first attempt at this measurement ran eighteen minutes on 520 lines, issuing `--param function=` one at a time. Every test called query_batch directly, so none of them noticed. CpgResult now carries run_batch and a test asserts the capability is reachable through the object the driver is handed. The earlier 275s->106s improvement attributed to batching came from region deduplication alone. **The budget stopped free work.** It bounds model calls, but was enforced by breaking the region loop -- spending a paid limit to stop unpaid CPG arbitration. 6 of 22 regions were examined and VAmPI's BOLA, which the graph entails for nothing, was never reached. It now withholds the judge only. 22 of 22 regions arbitrated, 17 counted as regions_unasked (silent because unaffordable is not silent because decided), and the BOLA is entailed by the model layer. **A region with no function asked about the whole repository.** Sending function="" matched every hit in the tree and the driver attributed that answer to whoever asked: one `host='0.0.0.0'` in app.py became eight identical entailed findings in eight files that do not contain it. Queries now carry the region's file. Entailed findings 14 -> 7, query time 70.9s -> 40.9s. The single-request form stays unscoped so the committed pair measurements remain reproducible. **The JVM had no heap bound.** Joern claimed a quarter of physical RAM and runs were killed under memory pressure at different points, so the numbers described the host rather than the engine. -J-Xmx2048m by default, OPENULTRASAST_CPG_HEAP_MB to raise it. Also: arbitrated findings carried `function:line` where the report layer read `path:line`, so every entailed finding reached a contributor with a function name where its file belonged; and the witness line was parsed by splitting on a comma, which produced sites like `config.py:17): permissive literal '0.0.0.0':?`. Reading: GO on one CPG per repository -- 6.2s to build, 177s end to end, 869MB, $0.0067, nothing infeasible. NO-GO on region-scoped taint as the only shape: VAmPI's SQL injection runs from a handler parameter into a function in another module, and a per-function region sees neither end. That is the ordinary shape of a real injection bug, so it is recorded as task 2.4 along with three smaller defects this run exposed. Gates byte-identical. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <[email protected]> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01T7XD7x5KonMdmGRkp63EQG |
||
|
Marius CiepluchandClaude Opus 5
|
c35426e186 |
perf(model): one Joern invocation per query kind, not one per region
JVM startup dominated a scan: a call per region per family put a ten-line file at 275s over three regions, and would have put a thousand regions at roughly fifty hours. The queries themselves are milliseconds once the CPG is loaded, so the cost was almost entirely process starts. scan_repository() is now collect -> batch -> arbitrate. The three .sc scripts accept a `requests` JSON map and answer all of them in one run, keeping the single-request form so the committed measurements stay reproducible byte-for-byte. Arbiters are untouched: each is handed a CpgResult whose `run` returns its own prefetched rows. The batcher builds parameters by calling request_params() extracted from taint.py, dominance.py and config_value.py rather than reconstructing them. A second copy that drifts from the arbiter's is the exact shape of the five family-assumption bugs the predecessor spec spent a session finding; there is now one definition per family and the batcher borrows it. Regions are also deduplicated by (path, function), collapsing the nameless entry-point rows that were producing `model:injection:?:10`. Measured on the same ten-line file: 275s -> 106s, three duplicate findings -> one `model:injection:ping:10`, rung unchanged at model_entailed. Gates byte-identical. Server mode is recorded as task 2.3, deliberately sequenced after the repository measurement: whether the remaining ~100s floor is worth a process model, a weakened subprocess seam and a Scala-evaluating HTTP endpoint depends on a build-time-to-query-time ratio only 2.2 produces. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <[email protected]> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01T7XD7x5KonMdmGRkp63EQG |
||
|
Marius CiepluchandClaude Opus 5
|
fe45081b43 |
fix(ci): run ruff format, and record run 5 at 90% pair-correct
CI was red on `ruff format --check`: 23 files. I ran `ruff check` after every
change this session and never once ran `ruff format --check`, though CI runs
both. Lint passing is not formatting passing, and I treated one as evidence for
the other for the whole session.
Formatting applied. The full CI sequence now reproduces locally: format, lint,
mypy over 94 files, 735 tests, three gates byte-identical, compileall, and the
semantic job's 16 marked tests.
Also records run 5 of the pipeline measurement, which the vampi fix lifted as
predicted:
hunter (K=5) pipeline (K=1)
pair-correct 76.7% 90.0%
leak 12.3% 6.7%
detection -- 96.7%
cost ~$0.69 $0.0068
27 of 30 pairs. Five runs, each step from a measurement contradicting an
assumption: 73.3 (no pipeline path) -> 73.3 (routing fixed, IDENTICAL, which
exposed the discarded verdict) -> 80.0 (residual question matched to its
arbiter) -> 86.7 (aiohttp settings) -> 90.0 (dominance question no longer
contradicting its own evidence).
One miss left: dsvpwa-dsvpwa-main, whose setting is an argparse --ssl default
rather than a security-setting call. Out of reach before the settings work and
still is; contorting the arbiter around one pair would be worse than the miss.
The caveat is recorded beside the number: 30 pairs of one slice, and the slice
iterated against all session. The +16% overfitting gap against vfc-js is why
contributor-scan Req 8.1/8.2 exist.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <[email protected]>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01T7XD7x5KonMdmGRkp63EQG
|
||
|
Marius CiepluchandClaude Opus 5
|
2b973dc0db |
feat(model-grounded-detection): tasks 2.1-2.2, the Joern seam and the taint verdict
The whole engine integration is one subprocess boundary: joern-parse builds a cpg.bin, joern --script runs a shipped CPGQL query that prints its JSON between fence markers, because Joern's stdout carries a banner and a REPL prompt around whatever a script emits. Nothing is imported in-process, so the core install keeps dependencies = [] -- a test walks the seam's AST to assert it imports only the standard library and names no JVM binding. Fail closed everywhere. A build or query that errors, times out, or prints something unparseable yields no verdict and the caller reports suspicion. The taint verdict distinguishes this from absence deliberately: a query returning None means "the engine could not decide", which is not "there is no flow", and conflating them is how a missing engine silently becomes a clean bill of health. The verdict is where the ladder earns its keep. An unsanitized source->sink path is model_entailed -- the graph establishes it and the LLM's claim is no longer load-bearing. A path a sanitizer may break is model_corroborated: the flow is real, but whether the sanitizer suffices is the semantic residual the LLM answers, checked against this verdict rather than averaged over runs. The chosen flow is picked by a total order (shortest, then lexicographic), so two runs over one CPG cannot disagree -- Req 6.4 asserted directly. The query itself is the part our flat IR could not do: reachableByFlows walks the PDG, so `q = "..." + request.args["x"]; execute(q)` is found, which is exactly the one-hop limit that held measured entailment at 2.2%. Capability detection reuses semantic/engines.joern_available rather than growing a second notion of "installed". The audit manifest is regenerated; the new modules are named by Req 4/5/6 rather than counted as orphans. Task 2.3, the go/no-go measurement, needs Joern installed and has not run. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <[email protected]> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01T7XD7x5KonMdmGRkp63EQG |