mirror of
https://github.com/norandom/OpenUltraSAST.git
synced 2026-10-18 12:39:28 +00:00
120 lines
8.7 KiB
Markdown
120 lines
8.7 KiB
Markdown
# Group 7 implementation and verification
|
||
|
||
The maintainer authorized all of group 7 on 2026-09-13. Fresh agent dispatch failed
|
||
with `agent thread limit reached`; kiro-impl's explicit manual fallback applies.
|
||
Reviews here are main-context reviews, not independent reviewer evidence.
|
||
Rollout remains NO-GO and the default capability registry remains empty.
|
||
|
||
## Task 7.1 brief
|
||
|
||
Requirements 1.1, 1.3, 1.4, 4.1, 5.1–5.5 and 7.1; design: Snapshot Adapter,
|
||
Push runner, Result and Hook Adapter. Consume every Git update and remote identity,
|
||
resolve exact comparisons using the existing adapter, share one absolute budget,
|
||
retain independent finding/coverage/enforcement statuses and all comparison evidence.
|
||
Verify real stdin delivery, immutable readable snapshots, deduplication, missing bases,
|
||
deletions, no work, policy combinations and deadline ownership.
|
||
|
||
## Status Report
|
||
- STATUS: READY_FOR_REVIEW
|
||
- TASK: 7.1
|
||
- RED_PHASE_OUTPUT: `/tmp/group7-1-red.log`: four failures with the interface switch OFF. ON: 37 focused tests passed; switch removed, final focused run: 29 passed (including 11 transaction controls).
|
||
- TESTS_RUN: full suite 1274 passed, 9 skipped in 109.09s; final targeted tests cover the subsequently added five policy combinations and retained resolved identity on preparation failure. Ruff and mypy pass.
|
||
- CONCERNS: synthetic admission controls prove enforcement, not detector eligibility. No capability enabled.
|
||
|
||
## Review Verdict
|
||
- VERDICT: APPROVED
|
||
- TASK: 7.1
|
||
- MECHANICAL_RESULTS: actual diff reviewed; full suite and final targeted checks pass; no new placeholders or credentials; boundary restricted to CLI, push runner and report.
|
||
- FINDINGS: fixed child stdin closure by duplicating Git's descriptor before forking; remote URL is hashed rather than storing possible credentials; unresolved comparison identity survives preparation failure.
|
||
- RED phase: VERIFIED.
|
||
- SUMMARY: One transaction retains every resolved ref and completed scan without resetting the analysis deadline.
|
||
|
||
## Verification Result
|
||
- STATUS: VERIFIED
|
||
- CLAIM_TYPE: TASK
|
||
- CLAIM: Task 7.1 interface and policy integration implemented.
|
||
- EVIDENCE: `/tmp/group7-1-full.log`, `/tmp/group7-1-final-focused.log`; ruff, mypy and diff checks exit 0.
|
||
- GAPS: Representative multi-ref performance and real capability admission remain group 8 work.
|
||
|
||
## Task 7.2 brief
|
||
|
||
Requirements 1.2, 5.3, 5.4 and 7.4; design: Result and Hook Adapter.
|
||
Deliver executable opt-in integration and non-overwriting installation, preserve the
|
||
configured hook path, explicitly chain a prior hook with its exact input/arguments,
|
||
retain rejection, and document guarded removal. The existing hook's runtime remains
|
||
its own behavior; input retention and Safety Net analysis share one deadline.
|
||
Verify with disposable repositories and a local bare remote, never this project's hooks.
|
||
|
||
## Debug Report
|
||
- ROOT_CAUSE: `git rev-parse --path-format=absolute --git-path hooks/pre-push` canonicalizes the final symlink, so even O_EXCL on the returned name creates its target. Initial attribution to shell noclobber was not supported by the subsequent test.
|
||
- CATEGORY: LOGIC_ERROR
|
||
- FIX_PLAN: Resolve only `hooks`, append the literal `pre-push` basename, and create with O_EXCL/O_NOFOLLOW.
|
||
- VERIFICATION: Dangling-symlink regression passes; target remains absent.
|
||
- NEXT_ACTION: RETRY_TASK
|
||
- CONFIDENCE: HIGH
|
||
- NOTES: Git documents absolute output as canonical: https://git-scm.com/docs/git-rev-parse/2.33.0.html . Guarded removal instructions use directory-only resolution too.
|
||
|
||
## Status Report
|
||
- STATUS: READY_FOR_REVIEW
|
||
- TASK: 7.2
|
||
- RED_PHASE_OUTPUT: `/tmp/group7-2-red.log` (missing integration); `/tmp/group7-2-flag-off.log` (two failures with chaining OFF). ON: three passed; switch removed, final 16 hook/interface tests passed.
|
||
- TESTS_RUN: full regression 1282 passed, 9 skipped in 119.95s; final 16 focused tests include subsequently added exact-exit and symlink controls. Ruff, formatting, mypy, shell syntax, CLI help and diff checks pass.
|
||
- CONCERNS: input-retention failure stops the integration because a prior hook cannot safely receive partial input. Prior hook runtime remains separate from analysis.
|
||
|
||
## Review Verdict
|
||
- VERDICT: APPROVED
|
||
- TASK: 7.2
|
||
- MECHANICAL_RESULTS: actual diff and installation/removal recipes reviewed; disposable remote accepts/rejects correctly; original stdin bytes/arguments and exact nonzero exit preserved; source/index/ref state and core.hooksPath preserved; no placeholders or secrets; task boundary maintained.
|
||
- FINDINGS: final-path canonicalization issue repaired and regression tested. Installation is explicit and does not overwrite existing hooks or symlink targets.
|
||
- RED phase: VERIFIED.
|
||
- SUMMARY: Opt-in integration preserves prior hook behavior and supports guarded restoration.
|
||
|
||
## Verification Result
|
||
- STATUS: VERIFIED
|
||
- CLAIM_TYPE: TASK
|
||
- CLAIM: Task 7.2 non-destructive hook integration delivered.
|
||
- EVIDENCE: `/tmp/group7-2-full.log`, `/tmp/group7-2-final-focused.log`; static checks and shell/CLI smoke exit 0.
|
||
- GAPS: No hook installed in this project's actual repository; rollout remains NO-GO.
|
||
|
||
## Task 7.3 brief
|
||
|
||
Requirements 3.5, 4.1, 4.2 and 7.1–7.3; design: Delta and Actionability Policy,
|
||
Push runner and existing endpoint/redaction integration. Explicit endpoint/model only,
|
||
one remaining deadline, no-model identity preserved. Assistance selects existing
|
||
admitted witness indices and cannot contribute prose, evidence, a rung or a finding.
|
||
Record prompt/model/usage/cost provenance and retain deterministic fallback. Verify
|
||
misleading/delayed replies, outbound redaction, no unadmitted input, and an actual
|
||
loopback HTTP request through the existing endpoint adapter. No external provider used.
|
||
|
||
## Status Report
|
||
- STATUS: READY_FOR_REVIEW
|
||
- TASK: 7.3
|
||
- RED_PHASE_OUTPUT: `/tmp/group7-3-red.log`: six failures with the feature OFF, default no-model identity passes. ON: seven passed; switch removed. Final assistance/report suite: 27 passed, including endpoint receipts, delayed/misleading replies, redaction, dotenv isolation and witness/location binding.
|
||
- TESTS_RUN: full suite 1295 passed, 9 skipped in 149.70s; final 27 focused tests validate the subsequent renderer binding refinement. Ruff, formatting (254 files), mypy (115 source files), compileall and diff checks pass.
|
||
- CONCERNS: cost is explicitly unknown when receipt/pricing is missing; cancelled remote requests may still incur provider cost. All provider tests use synthetic clients or loopback HTTP. No normal capability enabled.
|
||
|
||
## Review Verdict
|
||
- VERDICT: APPROVED
|
||
- TASK: 7.3
|
||
- MECHANICAL_RESULTS: actual code/diff reviewed against requirements 3.5, 4.1, 4.2 and 7.1–7.3. Regression/static checks pass. No new placeholders, hardcoded credentials or scope/ranking/admission changes. Synthetic key strings occur only in redaction controls.
|
||
- FINDINGS: repaired implicit pre-deadline dotenv loading; explicit configuration reuses the existing loader with dotenv disabled. Model-selected witness location and change explanation remain bound to that witness's admitted disposition. Incomplete usage is never priced as zero. Unknown/extra model response fields cannot create claims.
|
||
- RED phase: VERIFIED.
|
||
- SUMMARY: Optional assistance is bounded presentation selection over existing admitted evidence, with deterministic fallback.
|
||
|
||
## Verification Result
|
||
- STATUS: VERIFIED
|
||
- CLAIM_TYPE: TASK
|
||
- CLAIM: Task 7.3 and group 7 integration are implemented and locally verified.
|
||
- EVIDENCE: `/tmp/group7-final-suite.log` (1295 passed, 9 skipped), `/tmp/group7-3-final-assistance-report.log` (27 passed), `/tmp/group7-3-final-focused.log` (34 passed). Detection gate 44/47, FP 0/44; map gate PASS; pair gate 3/3, labeled 28/28, zero fix leaks. Ruff, mypy, formatting, compileall and shell syntax pass. Docker build exit 0; image `sha256:af5b896b406fe98acb3d00bb2180a7549febd6dd285f0b63087538118e52e1f4`. Network-disabled packaged CLI help and real empty Git-stdin transaction both exit 0 as UID 1000; readable 1085-byte artifact records `not_applicable`, model disabled, no scans.
|
||
- GAPS: Packaged smoke verifies liveness and input/report integration, not detection performance or alert eligibility. Main-context review fallback is not independent review. Group 8 remains pending and rollout remains NO-GO.
|
||
|
||
## Current specification status
|
||
|
||
Requirements, design and tasks remain approved. Implementation: 23/27 executable
|
||
subtasks complete (85.2%); groups 1–7 complete, group 8 has four pending tasks.
|
||
No new implementation blocker. Upstream contributor-scan contracts and existing ranker
|
||
remain unchanged. Revalidate multi-ref deadline/cancellation, hook failures and model
|
||
fallback in group 8.1, representative changed-code performance in 8.2, independent
|
||
capability admission in 8.3, and packaged end-to-end usefulness in 8.4. The accepted
|
||
rollout gates are unchanged; zero enabled capabilities cannot satisfy them.
|